The Columbus Blue Jackets were defeated by the Pittsburgh Penguins, 5 to 4, in overtime in Game 3 of the 2017 Eastern Conference First Round on April 16, 2017.

The Columbus Blue Jackets were defeated by the Pittsburgh Penguins, 5 to 4, in overtime in Game 3 of the 2017 Eastern Conference First Round on April 16, 2017.
1st period
PIT
CBJ
Cam Atkinson (EV) assisted by Brandon Dubinsky and Nick Foligno
0
1
Jake Guentzel (EV) assisted by Sidney Crosby and Ron Hainsey
1
1
Cam Atkinson (EV) unassisted
1
2
Zach Werenski (PP) assisted by Nick Foligno and Sam Gagner
1
3
2nd period
PIT
CBJ
Bryan Rust (EV) assisted by Evgeni Malkin and Brian Dumoulin
2
3
Evgeni Malkin (EV) unassisted
3
3
3rd period
PIT
CBJ
Jake Guentzel (PP) assisted by Phil Kessel and Evgeni Malkin
4
3
Brandon Dubinsky (EV) assisted by Jack Johnson and Oliver Bjorkstrand
4
4
OT
PIT
CBJ
Jake Guentzel (EV) assisted by Sidney Crosby
5
4