The Toronto Maple Leafs lost to the New York Rangers, 2 to 1, in overtime in Game 5 of the 1940 Stanley Cup Finals on April 11, 1940.

The Toronto Maple Leafs lost to the New York Rangers, 2 to 1, in overtime in Game 5 of the 1940 Stanley Cup Finals on April 11, 1940.
1st period
NYR
TOR
Neil Colville (EV) assisted by Mac Colville and Alex Shibicky
1
0
2nd period
NYR
TOR
Syl Apps (EV) unassisted
1
1
OT2
NYR
TOR
Muzz Patrick (EV) assisted by Neil Colville
2
1