The New York Giants lost to the Baltimore Colts, 23 to 17, in the 1958 NFL championship game on December 28, 1958.

The New York Giants lost to the Baltimore Colts, 23 to 17, in the 1958 NFL championship game on December 28, 1958.
1st quarter
BAL
NYG
Pat Summerall 36-yard field goal
0
3
2nd quarter
BAL
NYG
Alan Ameche 2-yard run (Steve Myhra kick)
7
3
Raymond Berry 15-yard pass from Johnny Unitas (Steve Myhra kick)
14
3
3rd quarter
BAL
NYG
Mel Triplett 1-yard run (Pat Summerall kick)
14
10
4th quarter
BAL
NYG
Frank Gifford 15-yard pass from Charlie Conerly (Pat Summerall kick)
14
17
Steve Myhra 20-yard field goal
17
17
OT
BAL
NYG
Alan Ameche 1-yard run
23
17