The Cleveland Browns pulled it off against the New York Jets, 23 to 20, in the 1986 AFC divisional game on January 3, 1987.

The Cleveland Browns pulled it off against the New York Jets, 23 to 20, in the 1986 AFC divisional game on January 3, 1987.
1st quarter
NYJ
CLE
Wesley Walker 42-yard pass from Pat Ryan (Pat Leahy kick)
7
0
Herman Fontenot 37-yard pass from Bernie Kosar (Mark Moseley kick)
7
7
2nd quarter
NYJ
CLE
Mark Moseley 38-yard field goal
7
10
Pat Leahy 46-yard field goal
10
10
3rd quarter
NYJ
CLE
Pat Leahy 37-yard field goal
13
10
4th quarter
NYJ
CLE
Freeman McNeil 25-yard run (Pat Leahy kick)
20
10
Kevin Mack 1-yard run (Mark Moseley kick)
20
17
Mark Moseley 22-yard field goal
20
20
OT2
NYJ
CLE
Mark Moseley 27-yard field goal
20
23